Julianna and Kelley dissect “An Inconvenient Study,” a documentary from the creators of Vaxxed that claims 54% of American children have chronic illnesses caused by vaccines. The film features Del Bigtree’s undercover footage of a Henry Ford Health researcher who conducted a flawed retrospective study comparing vaccinated and unvaccinated children. The hosts connect this documentary’s rhetoric to RFK Jr’s current HHS proposals for similar Medicare/Medicaid studies, explaining why retrospective designs cannot establish causation and are vulnerable to bias. They emphasize the importance of consulting pediatricians rather than falling for fear-based messaging.
Key Takeaways:
- “An Inconvenient Study” claims all childhood vaccines cause chronic illness in 54% of children
- The documentary centers on a retrospective study that Henry Ford Health rejected for not meeting methodological standards
- Retrospective studies look at existing data but cannot prove causation and are vulnerable to bias
- RFK Jr is proposing similar retrospective studies using Medicare/Medicaid data, which isn’t a representative population
- The documentary uses the same rhetoric Kennedy employs about “balance” and hearing anti-vaccine voices
- Scaling up a flawed study design doesn’t fix its fundamental problems
- The film is part of the autism industrial complex fear mongering
- Anti-vaccine movement is gaining traction by creating skepticism about settled science
- Parents should consult their pediatricians about vaccine decisions, not documentaries
Transcript
[Kelley] (0:10 – 0:45)
Hi, I’m Kelley Jensen, I’m here with my friend Julianna Scott, we’re the Refrigerator Moms, and we’ve got a Cold Hard Truth episode today about another documentary that you watched so we don’t have to.
[Julianna]
You’re welcome.
[Kelley]
And you have it summarized here, you’re going to put the summary up on our website.
[Julianna]
This one, the name of this documentary is An Inconvenient Study, brought to you by the same people that brought you Vaxxed and Vaxxed 2. All right, so what did we learn? Another conspiracy theory.
[Kelley]
And An Inconvenient Study is the documentary that Jenny McCarthy was on the red carpet.
[Julianna] (0:46 – 0:59)
She was. She went to the premiere. I learned about it from her social media.
[Kelley]
And you chased it down.
[Julianna]
I did, I did. I chased it down to YouTube. It was free, at least. I didn’t have to pay for this one.
[Kelley]
Oh, good.
[Julianna]
So let me give you the quick—
[Kelley] (0:59 – 1:07)
All right, but before you do, we are going to say that this Study is part of the autism industrial complex fear portion, right?
[Julianna] (1:07 – 1:09)
Oh, yeah. This is all fear mongering.
[Kelley] (1:09 – 1:14)
Fear mongering, or they would allege it’s science, though. Yes.
[Julianna] (1:14 – 1:14)
Yes.
[Kelley] (1:15 – 1:23)
But you know, when is science fear? The science of fear. Still part of the complex.
[Julianna] (1:23 – 1:23)
Yes. Still well within. Still well within the complex. The autism money machine.
[Kelley] (1:24 – 1:24)
Yes.
[Julianna] (1:24 – 2:03)
Yes. Definitely. So right at the outset, they’re not just focused on autism in this one. It’s definitely part of it. And they give you a little rundown on Vaxxed and Vaxxed 2.
[Kelley] (2:04 – 2:04)
Of course.
[Julianna] (2:04 – 3:29)
In this one, they claim that 54% of American children have a chronic illness brought on by vaccines. Right up front, they’re just saying it. They do broaden the scope, not only on the illnesses, but they say it’s not just the MMR vaccine, but all childhood vaccines. So this one is targeting the whole thing. So they have moms not just talking about autism and how the MMR vaccine caused their autism. Some actually were saying that other ones caused their autism, which was new. But they were saying, my child had the flu vaccine and now this happened to him. My child got a vaccine and immediately this happened. So it’s covering all these injured children from vaccinations. But the center of the documentary is about the conspiracy behind silencing this doctor who wrote a report—he’s out of Henry Ford Health—and he did a retrospective study comparing vaccinated and unvaccinated children across multiple health outcomes. So he said, I can do this study, I have this data. I will just look at the unvaccinated and the vaccinated and see all of the incidences of all these different chronic conditions.
[Kelley] (3:30 – 3:30)
And so what was his name?
[Julianna] (3:32 – 6:16)
I don’t know. It’s in the documentary. But it’s interesting because Del Bigtree is the producer, but he also is the narrator of the documentary. He does this whole sting operation where he had talked to this doctor about doing this retrospective study. And then he, the doctor, decides, oh, I’m not going to publish it because the PR team here told me I was going to get fired. So he meets him for dinner and he has a pen camera and so you have to watch this guy, this poor doctor, through a water glass most of the time. And he’s basically saying, I didn’t want to lose my job over this and it wasn’t worth it. And he says there were flaws to the study. But Bigtree is says, you said you were at the end of your career anyway, and it didn’t really matter when you were pushing this. So you see a lot of this pocket pen cam.
[Kelley]
The drama.
[Julianna]
Yeah, it was very cloak and dagger like that. But Henry Ford Health comes out and says that the study didn’t meet the methodological standards for publication, that retrospective designs can’t establish causation. And they silenced it. It wasn’t like they silenced it. They said this just isn’t good science. And there is a moment where Bigtree does acknowledge that it wasn’t the smoking gun about vaccines causing autism. So that was one little snippet. He says there wasn’t enough data to bolster his claim. So he just says he just needs more data, which leads me to the connection—which is why I think this is important—to Kennedy and the HHS. They have been talking about doing a retrospective study with Medicare and Medicaid patients. So you’ve heard of this.
[Kelley]
Yeah.
[Julianna]
So this is the problem. The retrospective study looks backward at existing data rather than following participants in the future. So the strengths are it’s fast, it’s less expensive. They already have the data. But it doesn’t prove causation and it’s vulnerable to bias. That’s the big issue. So Kennedy saying that he wants to do this with Medicare and Medicaid—it’s not a representative population.
[Kelley] (6:17 – 6:17)
Right.
[Julianna] (6:17 – 6:25)
So that’s going to be an issue and it’s a weak and flawed study as it is. And so scaling it up isn’t going to fix that.
[Kelley] (6:25 – 6:27)
Yeah. Not going to change the parameters of the study.
[Julianna] (6:27 – 6:43)
No, it’s not going to change it. But a lot of the rhetoric and language in this documentary is like what we’re hearing when Kennedy’s standing up speaking to the whole country. So this guy’s preaching to the choir. I don’t know who is watching An Inconvenient Study. Everyone’s dug in.
[Kelley] (6:43 – 6:43)
Other than you.
[Julianna] (6:43 – 6:46)
Thanks.
[Kelley] (6:46 – 6:46)
Thanks.
[Julianna] (6:47 – 6:53)
But everyone’s dug in. We’ve talked about the anti-vax movement. They believe it.
[Kelley] (6:53 – 6:53)
Right.
[Julianna] (6:53 – 7:48)
They think they’re being listened to. So they’re not going to change their minds.
[Kelley]
Right.
[Julianna]
But Kennedy is changing people’s minds. He’s bringing people into the movement. And part of the language they’re using is that it needs to be “balanced.” We’ve heard from all these scientists and now you need to hear this information from us and there needs to be more voices in it. So that’s a problem. And they’re saying that it’s too biased now toward pro-vaccine. So you need to have this balance of the anti-vax movement.
[Kelley]
Just to say you did.
[Julianna]
So you can learn, so that you can make your own decision. They’re all about no mandates, nothing about vaccines. You should be able to make your own decision about vaccines. And if you want to injure your child by giving your child a vaccine, that’s your decision. You go right ahead.
[Kelley] (7:49 – 8:59)
If you’re a parent and, or you’re pregnant about to become a parent, what I would want to hear from people who support that approach is, what happens to my child if my child gets the disease?
[Julianna]
Right.
[Kelley]
We love The Pitt. We love that episode of The Pitt with the child that had the measles. I don’t want anything to do with that if I’m a parent. What are the odds of that? Talk to your doctor. Talk to your pediatrician that you’re in the room with.
[Julianna] (8:59 – 9:44)
Right. The connection is getting amplified between Kennedy and this movement, which he is very closely aligned with—we know these are talking points. They’re just revisiting settled questions. It’s just keeping that fear going. It’s that fear that leads to talk about prevention. We want to prevent this from happening. The autism industrial complex.
[Kelley]
Yes.
[Julianna]
They’re still saying you need to be skeptical. We know the numbers are going up. People are listening to this message.
[Kelley] (9:47 – 9:56)
Well, buyer beware, right? All we can do is encourage people to talk to those people that they’re in the room with and make their decisions based on that.
[Julianna] (9:56 – 10:51)
Unfortunately we are now entering this era where we’re all skeptics now. Now we’re skeptical. What is the government telling us? We’re all being skeptical of everything now. But trust your doctor.
[Kelley]
Talk to your doctor. Trust your gut. Thanks.
[Julianna]
Thank you for listening to this episode of The Refrigerator Moms. We have a free download that includes a full list of practical to-dos we shared in this episode on our website.
Our refrigerator paper, our version of the white paper includes additional what-would-we-dos and background information on everything we talked about today. Find it on our website, RefrigeratorMoms.com, where you can also sign up for our newsletter. We’d also love to hear your questions.
Send them in along with future podcast topics by connecting with us on your favorite social media.
Please note that the information provided in this podcast is for informational purposes only, and it is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding medical conditions. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have heard on this podcast.
The opinions and views expressed in this podcast are solely those of the hosts and guests. Any recommendations or suggestions made are based on personal experiences and beliefs and should not be taken as definitive advice. It’s important to consult with appropriate professionals for personalized guidance.
This transcript has been edited for clarity and readability.