Julianna and Kelley examine the “Autism Industrial Complex” through the lens of Mattel’s new Autistic Barbie doll. Drawing from a 2022 book, they break down how autism has become a multi-billion dollar business driven by hope, fear, and claims of science. The hosts critique how ABA therapy, genetic research, and products like Autistic Barbie perpetuate this system while often excluding severely autistic individuals from the conversation. They discuss vaccination fearmongering, corporate tokenism, and whether interventions are truly helpful or just profitable. With their signature honesty, they challenge listeners to question what’s driving autism advocacy and research.
Key Takeaways:
- The Autism Industrial Complex operates on three pillars: hope, fear, and truth (science rhetoric)
- ABA therapy evolved from acknowledging limitations to promising normalization
- Autism Awareness Month shifted to Autism Acceptance Month, reflecting changing narratives
- Anti-vaccination movements exploit fear to drive the autism prevention industry
- Severely autistic individuals are consistently excluded from autism advocacy conversations
- Autistic Barbie was developed with the Autism Self Advocacy Network over 18 months
- Mattel donated only 1,000 Autism Barbies to children’s hospitals
- The book suggests avoiding diagnosis and interventions to escape the industrial complex
- Parents shouldn’t bankrupt themselves pursuing interventions driven by hope or fear
- Being part of the autism conversation inevitably makes you part of the industrial complex
Transcript
[Kelley] (0:09 – 0:24)
Hi, I’m Kelley Jensen. This is my friend Julianna Scott. We are the Refrigerator Moms. And today we have a Cold Hard Truth episode where we lay down cold hard facts about all things neurodivergent. Today we have a special guest.
[Julianna]
Oh, who is she?
[Kelley]
Autism Barbie. Isn’t she cute?
[Julianna] (0:25 – 0:34)
She’s cute. And if you are listening to us, go over to our YouTube channel and you can meet Barbie.
[Kelley] (0:35 – 0:50)
Autism Barbie. So what I want to know, the burning question, is Barbie part of the Autism Industrial Complex?
[Julianna]
Well, she is.
[Kelley]
She is. I would agree. Sorry, Barb, but you are part of the Autism Industrial Complex, which is what?
[Julianna] (0:50 – 1:44)
Well, the Autism Industrial Complex is the title of a book that came out in 2022. And it is all about the capitalism and consumerism surrounding autism. And it is a very dense book. And it is a play on Eisenhower’s military industrial complex ideas. The author is now basically saying that that maps on perfectly to this Autism Industrial Complex, that basically anything surrounding autism and intervention and prevention, it just permeates the culture. And we don’t even think twice. Like, we don’t think twice about spending all this money on certain research or certain interventions because now it’s just become normalized. So it’s the business of autism.
[Kelley] (2:22 – 2:34)
So this author has categorized the business of autism as becoming normalized. So this is the business of autism into three major categories, right?
[Julianna] (2:35 – 4:20)
Fear? Yes. First, it started with hope. First, she says back in our Leo Kanner days, they introduced the idea of autism as a problem. So then we have this idea that autism is a problem to be solved.
[Kelley]
OK.
[Julianna]
And then it morphs into the ideology of hope. We talk about all these people, these characters—[Ivar] Lavaas from UCLA, who was the father of ABA. He originally said, we’re not really not going to make your child normal through this. But then, at some point, he pivots and starts changing his rhetoric to give parents hope that through ABA their child can become more normal.
[Kelley]
OK.
[Julianna]
So that’s when ABA becomes the gold standard intervention. And this author really takes issue—and she really goes after ABA and everyone surrounding it, like the certification board. And she couples the ABA groups with the non-autistic parents and the advocacy that non-autistic parents are doing by pushing legislators and pushing everyone to put more dollars into genetic research, all these other things that are trying to cure autism. So there’s intervention, there’s prevention. There’s certain things that drive the complex.
[Kelley] (4:21 – 4:21)
Right. And the business of autism.
[Julianna] (4:22 – 5:10)
Right. So there are these ideas that there’s hope, which means that my child will be normal, and then there’s fear and that fuels prevention. Fear pushes people to try to cure it and prevent it. And that’s what RFK Jr.’s peddling—this whole idea of fear. Don’t take Tylenol, don’t vaccinate your kids or your kid will get autism. And that’s a tragedy. So this talk about epidemics is feeding the beast of this complex because then more dollars are going to be spent. And everyone now in this world, this complex, is invested in this business. And it’s a multi-billion dollar business.
[Kelley] (5:11 – 5:28)
Right. Once again, severe autism is totally left out of this conversation, are they not?
[Julianna]
Yeah, pretty much.
[Kelley]
Right. Because they are unable to advocate for themselves. I would argue that Barbie is leaving severely autistic people out of the conversation altogether.
[Julianna] (5:28 – 5:29)
She is.
[Kelley] (5:30 – 5:39)
In the Autism Industrial Complex, would you label Barbie as fear, intervention, hope? What is Barbie?
[Julianna] (5:40 – 6:02)
Well, I want to say fear. I’m scared of this. No, she’s definitely in the hope category.
[Kelley]
Yes.
[Julianna]
And that’s another thing that this author says . . . there used to be Autism Awareness month.
[Kelley] (6:02 – 6:02)
Yes.
[Julianna] (6:03 – 6:25)
And that was all about highlighting the problem.
[Kelley]
Right.
[Julianna]
Stoking fear. Then it switched to Autism Acceptance month. And that is hopeful. And she’s says, it’s not all bad, but it’s also not all good.
[Kelley]
All right. So let’s keep going. So, Barbie’s hope. What is ABA science?
[Julianna]
Yes, there’s truth.
[Kelley] (6:25 – 6:25)
That’s right.
[Julianna] (6:26 – 6:35)
I forgot to mention that number three is truth. And that is all about the rhetoric of science. So you would say, ABA is science-based and that is feeding that.
[Kelley] (6:36 – 6:36)
Right.
[Julianna] (6:36 – 6:42)
But I think originally they would say that ABA came out of hope, hope that your child will be normal.
[Kelley] (6:42 – 6:46)
I would argue that it’s hope that your child would just be able to function.
[Julianna] (6:46 – 6:46)
Right.
[Kelley] (6:47 – 6:49)
And even just within your family.
[Julianna] (6:49 – 6:49)
Right.
[Kelley] (6:50 – 6:52)
What about vaccination?
[Julianna] (6:53 – 6:54)
That is all fear.
[Kelley] (6:54 – 7:17)
That’s fear. Well, people would argue that science though. Isn’t this interesting? So yeah, the overwhelming message of this episode and of the Autism Industrial Complex is be honest what you’re stoking. If you believe that vaccines cause autism, is that a fear? Yes. Or is that science? And we would argue that it’s fear.
[Julianna] (7:17 – 7:23)
Well, yes. All of the rhetoric surrounding the anti-vax movement is: don’t let this happen to your child.
[Kelley] (7:23 – 7:24)
A cautionary tale.
[Julianna] (7:24 – 8:02)
A cautionary tale. So what I think is interesting and go back to your original point about severe autism, this is what’s really interesting. I was listening to this author. She was doing an interview and there was a Q&A session and people are asking, well, what do we do? And also, aren’t you part of the autism industry? And she did acknowledge she is in fact part of it.
[Kelley]
As are we.
[Julianna]
As are we, sure. The one thing I agree with that she says, you shouldn’t bankrupt yourself. You shouldn’t mortgage your house because you feel coerced into doing interventions by hope, fear, or science.
[Kelley] (8:02 – 8:02)
Right.
[Julianna] (8:02 – 9:02)
Everyone, slow your roll and do what you can do. We always say that. So I do agree with her on that front.
[Kelley]
Absolutely.
[Julianna]
When really pressed about what to do, she said go off grid. So if you are autistic, you would stay out of this capitalist structure. If you just didn’t get a diagnosis, if you didn’t get interventions, if you didn’t get support. She even said find jobs where you can find your own accommodations. And she is saying that 200 years ago, when people weren’t being diagnosed with autism, when it wasn’t a concept, people would say, oh, there’s that weird uncle and she said everyone has a weird uncle. And I’m thinking that is really not talking about the severely autistic population.
[Kelley] (9:02 – 9:04)
Never. They’re never mentioned.
[Julianna] (9:04 – 9:49)
Pivoting a little, let’s talk a little bit about Barbie. Okay, so Barbie, what does Barbie have? On YouTube, you’ll be able to see what we have. She’s got a fidget spinner, which I think is a little passé.
[Kelley] (9:49 – 10:12)
I think it is. Her hands move in such a way to allow for the child playing with her to be able to stim. Make Barbie stim, make Barbie stim.
[Julianna]
That’s a fun plot. Who wants to do that?
[Kelley]
She got an adaptive technology device because we’re supposed to assume nonverbal. And she’s got headphones to drown out the noise.
[Julianna] (10:12 – 10:17)
Nice. Oh, and I noticed that she’s wearing a nice loose fitting dress because she might have some sensory issues.
[Kelley] (10:17 – 10:39)
A bit short, a little short. Sexualization of autistic Barbie, in my opinion. I would prefer she wear underpants.
[Julianna]
I would prefer so too. And she’s got some nice flats. A nice stable, stable flat.
[Kelley]
She took 18 months of collaboration between Mattel and the Autism Self Advocacy Network.
[Julianna] (10:40 – 10:45)
Kudos to Mattel for reaching out to an organization that keeps autistic people central. I do appreciate that.
[Kelley] (10:45 – 10:46)
I do too.
[Julianna] (10:46 – 11:01)
I believe, can’t any Barbie be autistic? Maybe you just throw in some accessories for your existing Barbie and that would have sufficed. Sure, throw in a fidget spinner. Although can we get something updated? Maybe that was good because you could put it on her thumb.
[Kelley] (11:01 – 11:26)
Also, I would like to say that we did some reading on this and we learned that Mattel has donated one thousand of these $11 Barbies to children’s hospitals. That’s it. That’s the extent of their donation to autism in any form is one thousand $11 dolls, and I definitely think that qualifies as part of the Autism Industrial Complex.
[Julianna] (11:26 – 11:31)
100%. We also forgot to share her gaze. She’s not making direct eye contact.
[Kelley] (11:32 – 11:39)
She’s not, although I’m used to that. So, it’s nice to meet you Barbie. Thanks for tuning in.
[Julianna] (11:39 – 11:45)
Like and subscribe and if you like our podcast, give us a five star rating.
[Kelley] (11:45 – 11:46)
Have a great day.
This transcript has been edited for clarity and readability.