Julianna Scott and Kelley Jensen dig into a storyline from the hit medical drama The Pitt, where autistic character Becca is treated for a UTI and her sister Dr. Mel invokes “supported decision-making.” The hosts applaud the show for raising the topic — then spend the episode unpacking everything it glossed over. From the legal mechanics of conservatorship to the near-total absence of guidance around reproductive health for disabled adults, Julianna and Kelley get into the weeds so the show didn’t have to. Kelley also shares the surprisingly sweet story of securing conservatorship for her own son before his 18th birthday.
Key Takeaways
- The Pitt introduced “supported decision-making” to a mainstream audience — a real legal framework worth understanding
- No state in the U.S. allows anyone to make reproductive decisions on behalf of another adult, including through conservatorship
- Conservatorship varies significantly by state and comes in different categories: financial, healthcare, and more
- Supported decision-making lets the individual retain final authority while supporters explain options and consequences — but it raises many unanswered questions
- Sexual and reproductive health for disabled adults is one of the least-guided, most legally complex areas of disability care
- Conservatorship can be suspended or revoked if circumstances change — it’s not necessarily permanent
- Start conversations about conservatorship and reproductive health at puberty, not at age 18
- Loop in your child’s pediatrician early — documented conversations can help you advocate later
- Don’t use Britney Spears as your benchmark for conservatorship — her case was extreme and atypical
- Informal supported decision-making is something many autism families are already practicing without realizing it
Transcript
Julianna Scott [0:00:10] Hi, I’m Julianna Scott. I’m here with Kelley Jensen and we’re the Refrigerator Moms. Today we’re talking about one of our favorite shows, The Pitt. Big fans, especially big fans of Dr. Mel and her sister Becca. Becca is autistic. Well, so is Mel. Becca is specifically called out as autistic. Dr. Mel has yet to be actually named, but I’m gonna diagnose her as autistic. But I think it’s a really interesting subplot on many levels, because it is absolutely. But one thing that cropped up on an episode, I think a week or so ago was when Becca comes into the ER and she is diagnosed with a UTI from having lots of sex. And the question comes up about whether or not she needs to disclose this to her sister.
Kelley Jensen [0:01:08] Right.
Julianna Scott [0:01:09] So Mel, Dr. Mel is asked, are you Becca’s legal guardian? And then Mel replies, no, I have durable power of attorney. And then she adds, but we did this thing called supported decision making where she can make her own decisions. So this was really interesting to me. I had never heard of supported decision making. Of course, I’d heard of conservatorship. And so it’s clear that Mel is not her conservator.
Kelley Jensen [0:01:36] Right, well, but we’ll talk about that. Yeah, she might be. Are you taking care of your brain? You’ve tried medication, you’ve gone to therapy, but has anyone talked to you about brain care? It is the mental health treatment no one has told you about. At Brain Performance Technologies, we help with depression, PTSD, autism, and many other mental health conditions. Our treatments are drug free and non invasive. Reach out to us about insurance options. BrainPerformanceTechnologies.com So, yes, so this brought up
Julianna Scott [0:02:08] a big conversation between us. It surprisingly brought up more questions than answers.
Kelley Jensen [0:02:14] So one of the things, as much as I love Mel and Becca, as much as I appreciate any representation, yes, it was so neat, such a neat little packaged bow that it almost, almost does more harm than good because it made it seem like so cut and dry and such an easy issue. And reproductive health, sexual health is one of the stickiest, grayest areas of care for people who have disabilities. And there is no answer. There’s most cases, no real guidance. And we didn’t get a whole lot of. We just got a whole lot more questions. Well, and — or the answer was always something that was neat and clean and affirmative. Right.
Julianna Scott [0:03:00] And that’s great for this show. I’m not knocking The Pitt.
Kelley Jensen [0:03:03] No, of course not. It’s not their job.
Julianna Scott [0:03:05] It’s not their job to educate people or to necessarily even represent this in its entirety. It’s impossible. That would be its own show and probably not as interesting.
Kelley Jensen [0:03:15] And nobody would watch it because their heads would explode from all of that. I can just do that right now. Okay, so — so Becca was having sex and she consented to it. In this case, they even made it easy for —
Julianna Scott [0:03:27] She initiated it. She initiated. So she has a boyfriend and so she —
Kelley Jensen [0:03:30] Adam.
Julianna Scott [0:03:31] Yes, I think.
Kelley Jensen [0:03:32] Yes.
Julianna Scott [0:03:33] And the question came up. Well, you know, because Mel’s concern was she wants to know, should she have been taken advantage of. No. She’s like, no, I initiated it.
Kelley Jensen [0:03:41] Cool. Stop right there. Because the full question is, can he consent? Oh, God, we don’t even know about that one. We don’t know. We don’t know if he can consent. That’s one thing. Did somebody use protection or is Becca bound to get pregnant? Yeah, don’t know.
Julianna Scott [0:03:55] And I mean, she’s getting UTIs.
Kelley Jensen [0:03:58] She’s getting UTIs. So we are assuming what, that there was no condom?
Julianna Scott [0:04:02] Right.
Kelley Jensen [0:04:02] I don’t know. This is how in the weeds you have to get with these things. And no one’s gonna do that. And it definitely does not make for good television. No, no, no.
Julianna Scott [0:04:11] Questioning how exactly Becca got UTIs is not great TV. But, you know, then, yes, everything was definitely in the positive, like, oh, she met his parents. It all sounded very, like, ideal. And interestingly, they focused more on Dr. Mel’s, like, oh, now I’m gonna be alone and I’m losing it. Well, I was — you know, I am concerned for Dr. Mel, of course, because she has her own stuff going on. But if we’re gonna look at Becca in this example, and we were asking, like, what’s her living situation? So we did a little Google dive on Becca’s living situation. So it sounds like she’s living in an apartment independently. Yeah.
Kelley Jensen [0:04:57] Independent living.
Julianna Scott [0:04:58] Independent living, but with some assistance. Yes, but that still doesn’t answer —
Kelley Jensen [0:05:05] It answers nothing. It answers nothing. So welcome to the world of sort of sexual and reproductive health of the disabled. There’s no answers. There’s no guidance. And it is a rich history of no answers, no guidance, abuse, trauma, you name it. So The Pitt was — but God bless The Pitt, they were at least doing their job by letting us know it’s out there.
Julianna Scott [0:05:28] Right, right. But let’s — let’s. Of course, I looked at what supported decision making is, and I wanted to know, like, what’s the difference between that and conservatorship?
Kelley Jensen [0:05:37] Okay.
Julianna Scott [0:05:37] And so —
Kelley Jensen [0:05:38] Well, first, do conservatorship first. What is conservatorship?
Julianna Scott [0:05:41] Well, okay, I think you’re better to answer that question because your son — yes. You went through this process.
Kelley Jensen [0:05:45] So first of all, conservatorship is different in every state. What it means is different in every state. But in general, there are levels to it. So there are categories. You can have a financial conservatorship, you can appeal for a — just some health decision making conservatorship, you could appeal for a blanket conservatorship. But in all cases of the various categories of conservatorship, there is not a category that covers reproductive health. So nobody in this country has the capacity to make reproductive decisions for another human being. That was something that was stomped out many, many years ago. But it also left little guidance, which is why there’s so many things that have gone wrong and so many — sadly, the idea was that it would stop some of these horrible things that were happening at the institutional level, and it’s just created other horrible things that have happened.
Julianna Scott [0:06:43] This episode of the Refrigerator Moms is brought to you by Brain Performance Technologies. Brain Performance Technologies is a specialty mental health clinic that offers Magnetic e-resonance therapy, or MeRT, for autistic people aged 3 or older. MeRT is a transcranial magnetic stimulation protocol that utilizes an EEG diagnostic to deliver personalized magnetic pulses to stimulate the brain and build neural pathways effective in managing autistic symptoms.
Kelley Jensen [0:07:10] Conservatorship means that you stand in the shoes of the disabled person and make decisions with the blessing of the courts. You have that authority, and it can extend to as many areas as allowed in your state. No state is gonna offer you reproductive rights. So there are some health, you know, for the healthcare decisions, financial decisions, living decisions, but not reproductive decisions. And in some states, supported decision making is a relatively new thing because a lot of people have moral objections to conservatorship, which we can get into — that’s an episode for another day. So supported decision making is supposed to pick up some of that slack where I don’t really have full blown conservatorship for you, but I help with these things.
Julianna Scott [0:07:56] Right, right. And so, and as you mentioned, not every state offers this, but some people are using it kind of as a framework. It’s like, so the individual retains the final decision making authority, but these supporters are saying that they explain the options, the consequences and the information, but they don’t override the person’s choices.
Kelley Jensen [0:08:18] Right. You know, but that just raises more questions. Where does that leave the supported decision making part? Like, where would that leave Mel in this situation?
Julianna Scott [0:08:26] Right.
Kelley Jensen [0:08:26] So —
Julianna Scott [0:08:27] Right.
Kelley Jensen [0:08:27] She has the right.
Julianna Scott [0:08:29] So these are formalized in writing, but it’s not — it doesn’t require court involvement.
Kelley Jensen [0:08:34] And does that make Mel legally bound by her sister’s decisions? So she decided to initiate sex with a boyfriend. What if she gets pregnant? Is Mel responsible for the baby? Supported decision making — does that cover that? And if Mel’s not responsible for the baby, what if Becca is unable to care for the baby?
Julianna Scott [0:08:53] Right. This is the same for conservatorship and for this supported decision making, but it requires trustworthy supporters.
Kelley Jensen [0:09:02] Right.
Julianna Scott [0:09:02] And this, you know, Becca is a —
Kelley Jensen [0:09:04] Or Mel is a very trustworthy —
Julianna Scott [0:09:06] Absolutely.
Kelley Jensen [0:09:06] Very, very trustworthy.
Julianna Scott [0:09:07] Absolutely. But, you know, is that universal?
Kelley Jensen [0:09:11] Hell no.
Julianna Scott [0:09:11] Nobody’s — at least the court evaluates you. Right. I mean, yes.
Kelley Jensen [0:09:16] So there is a process that you have to go through. My son’s conservatorship was actually a very sweet story. So it was before his 18th birthday. You have to get it done — generally, you have to get it done before they’re 18. And there are, like I said in our state, there are levels to it. And we were, you know, trying to go for levels and we had to go through — yeah — screening and he had to have his own representation. And we all worked together to establish. And then we went before a judge and the judge made the final decision. And, you know, you go into these family courts and we’re sitting there, you know, I want — of course you want him to be the first person, because he’s not going to want to sit there — but no, no, we were not first on the docket. We were seventh on the docket. So he had to sit there for seven people arguing about dad’s truck that should have been in their estate. You know, I mean, it was just on and on and on. Right, right. And — but to the judge’s credit, she moved through everything pretty quickly. But he’s — I mean, I think he’s being fairly well behaved, but he’s of course antsy because — yeah, it’s been about an hour — and then it’s our turn to get up and he blows into the microphone. And there was a printer in the judge’s quarters. And, you know, he loves printers. So he was obsessed with wanting — he wanted to go over and press the button. Yeah, we managed to get him to stop doing that. He blew into the microphone and our — I think it was his attorney that said, you know, he is here because his parents were requesting conservatorship. And the judge said “Grant.” It was awesome.
Julianna Scott [0:10:47] Like, I’ve been observing all day. You’re good.
Kelley Jensen [0:10:52] And now it is one of my favorite memories. And, you know, sometimes the system does work for you.
Julianna Scott [0:10:57] Right.
Kelley Jensen [0:10:57] So she was lovely. It was a lovely thing. And we all had a good laugh, and we went out and had a toast to his future because we, you know, felt that he was properly taken care of. Absolutely. Not everybody has that cute story, sadly.
Julianna Scott [0:11:10] No. No. So it is interesting. I think, that for those people who want that independence and are capable of that independence, it’s good. I don’t know enough about supported decision making to say this is a band aid or this is just a slightly more formal framework than just kind of like, listen to those people who care about you. Yeah.
Kelley Jensen [0:11:42] My suggestion to anybody that is struggling with what to do for their child, you can always suspend conservatorship. You can always renege it if the person feels that it is in their best interest to be on their own, to be independent — really explore what each of these options avails you to help your child with. Don’t assume that The Pitt got it right. Don’t assume that the attorneys for Britney Spears got it right. As I feel like, you know, we are all witnessing the Britney aftermath where conservatorship bad, you know, and Britney Spears was a very specific case.
Julianna Scott [0:12:22] Yes.
Kelley Jensen [0:12:22] That should not be any kind of a benchmark. So don’t go by Britney Spears and don’t have any preconceived notions. Talk to people. Talk to other parents. Talk to an attorney if it’s me. And if your child is able to communicate their intentions, do it long before 18. Do these things at the onset of puberty. Have these conversations at the onset of puberty, not on their 18th birthday. That’s too late.
Julianna Scott [0:12:47] Yeah, it’s too late.
Kelley Jensen [0:12:48] You should be doing it. Talk to the pediatrician. Make it part of their annual checkup. Okay. We’re 15. We’re working through reproductive health. We’ve done this, this and this. This is what’s sticking. This is what you know. These are issues that if the doctor has documented, the doctor can advocate, help you advocate for your child.
Julianna Scott [0:13:06] Right.
Kelley Jensen [0:13:06] So start early, ask questions and know your rights.
Julianna Scott [0:13:10] Yeah. And I would say, like, long time — when my son was, like, 8 or 9, we thought we were going to — I was starting to collect information about conservatorship and all that. I mean, that was our planned route.
Kelley Jensen [0:13:24] Yeah.
Julianna Scott [0:13:25] You know, we’d been told all the time that he wasn’t going to ever live independently, all these things. So I was just like, okay, you know, yeah, who’s my lawyer? All this stuff. And then, you know, it turned out that he was able to live independently and do these things. However, you know, we worked really hard to build trust with him.
Kelley Jensen [0:13:46] Right.
Julianna Scott [0:13:47] Regardless of that — so we can still have whatever influence. Yeah, you know, we can. And that he’s open to it. It’s not like we’re, you know, pushing our ideas, but, like, I mean, I would think that in some respects, in some aspects of his life, we are following this supported decision making model very informally.
Kelley Jensen [0:14:09] I would agree with you that you are. I mean, just knowing you personally and knowing, you know, your son, I think that you are, you are all working together. And he seems to have a good handle on when he needs to ask for help. And that is the ultimate goal.
Julianna Scott [0:14:23] Right, right. Because you are gonna have those who are able to make some decisions and you want them to have that autonomy and all of those things — you don’t wanna push. But, you know, it’s way more complex. I think that’s the point is just like, I love that there was this conversation and it made a good plot point and it’s a good starter, it’s
Kelley Jensen [0:14:45] a good jumping-off point for detailed conversations.
Julianna Scott [0:14:47] Right. But it’s — it’s never as tidy
Kelley Jensen [0:14:53] as a little
Julianna Scott [0:14:54] subplot on an amazing show.
Kelley Jensen [0:14:57] But we are grateful anyway for giving it a shot.
Julianna Scott [0:15:01] More Mel. More Becca.
Kelley Jensen [0:15:02] That’s right. Thanks for listening.
Julianna Scott [0:15:05] Thank you for listening to this episode of the Refrigerator Moms. We’d love to hear your questions. Send them in along with future podcast topics by connecting with us on your favorite social media. Please note that the information provided in this podcast is for informational purposes only and it is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding medical conditions. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have heard on this podcast. The opinions and views expressed in this podcast are solely those of the hosts and guests. Any recommendations or suggestions made are based on personal experiences and beliefs and should not be taken as definitive advice. It’s important to consult with appropriate professionals for personalized guidance.