Is Forcing Your Teen to Shower a Compliance Problem, Or a Hygiene One?

Julianna Scott and Kelley Jensen return for another social media questions episode, tackling the topics parents are actually asking about online. They dig into swearing as an expression of frustration, whether a nonverbal five-year-old will ever talk, what Glass Child Syndrome means for siblings, physical meltdowns directed at one parent, the fight over whether a teenager has to shower, and what happens when a parent asks about combining ABA with a PDA-focused support group. Julianna and Kelley weigh in with clinical experience and personal stories, showing why online advice rarely fits any one family.

Key Takeaways:

  • Swearing is often a form of communication or release, not just defiance
  • A swear jar or family word diet can turn cursing into a teaching moment
  • ABA should include alternative communication tools like PECS or sign language, not just spoken words
  • Five years old, or even three years of therapy, isn’t long enough to declare something isn’t working
  • Glass Child Syndrome describes siblings feeling overlooked, and it’s worth taking seriously
  • Physical aggression toward one parent usually signals an unmet communication or sensory need
  • Hitting a child to stop a behavior teaches hitting, it does not build regulation skills
  • Hygiene is not an arbitrary rule, and sensory-based shower struggles deserve real accommodations, not shame
  • Some online support groups shut down honest questions rather than answer them
  • Many PDA-focused strategies quietly borrow from ABA principles like antecedents and behavior triggers

Kelley 00:00
On today’s social media comments episode, we’re talking about all kinds of things, including what to do about swearing.

Julianna 00:11
Hi, and welcome back to the Refrigerator Moms. I’m Julianna. I’m here with my friend Kelley, and we are the Refrigerator Moms. So today, Kelley, you’re going to be telling me what’s out there on social media, because I won’t go near it.

Kelley 00:26
Yes. This is one of those episodes where I throw out some of the current topics people are asking questions about on the various social media channels. And I do my best to shock you.

Julianna 00:39
I know. 

Kelley 00:39
And today’s no exception.

Julianna 00:44
Okay, great. I’m ready. This time we’re laughing a little bit.

Kelley 00:45
Because these are supposed to be a surprise, but since I’m too vain to wear my reading glasses, you know that the first topic is swearing.

Julianna 00:57
I do. And I know something about will they ever talk?

Kelley 00:58
I know. That’s coming up.

Julianna 00:58
This is a good reading test. If you’re listening and not watching us on YouTube, go over to YouTube and you too can read Kelley’s notes.

Kelley 01:10
I’m not wearing my glasses. No judgment. My body, my choice. So large font it is.

Julianna 01:16
Okay.

Kelley 01:16
Okay. “My child is constantly swearing as a form of him expressing his frustrations at everything from the TV to the Xbox to his siblings. To me, it is disrespectful, jarring, scary to his siblings. And I worry that one day he’s going to swear at the wrong person. I assume he is modeling myself or my spouse, who are prone to swearing occasionally.” So what do you have to say about swearing, Julianna?

Julianna 01:39
Well, as you know, I like to swear. I like a good curse word. 

Kelley

You know what? I have to just say that when my son was first doing speech therapy, he was really not speaking at all. We were getting no words. And I was so frustrated because we were really working hard. And the speech therapist gave me a pep talk, and she said, sometimes the child has to hear it a thousand times. Keep going. I promise you’re going to hear sounds. You’re going to hear some language popping out of his mouth. And then I swear to God, the very next week, we were talking through notes, and he was playing with a toy, and he screamed the F word.

Julianna 02:19
Yeah. And did he hear it thousands of times? 

Kelley

I maintain that he did not hear it a thousand times. And she tried to make me feel better by saying, well sometimes those big expletives pack more of a punch and so they don’t need to be heard a thousand times. But I really tried to curb it.

Julianna 02:35
I think there is a moment of pride when your child uses a swear word appropriately.

Kelley 02:41
I was proud. I did go home and tell my husband that he knows the F word.

Julianna 02:47
And he used it correctly.

Kelley 02:47
Uh huh.

Julianna 02:47
Yes. So yeah, time and a place.

Kelley 02:56
Yes. But how do you teach that? And for a black and white thinker, the comments were all over the board. From the don’t try to censor him to everybody swears to it’s pretty hard to teach your child what you’re doing to do as you say.

Julianna 03:11
Again, big advocate of swearing. But there is a time and a place and hearing a kid curse regularly isn’t a great look and they could get in trouble. 

Kelley

And, well, swearing in classrooms and swearing at your child, at your sibling and swearing at the wrong person, can lead to physical violence. It can be a precursor to physical violence. The advice was all across the board. None of it was great. Letting them swear, no. But I think a word diet for the whole family is one of those things. I think that the swear jar is as good a tool as anything. And everybody has to put something in the swear jar, but try not to make it money. That’s what we used to try and do fun things, like write another word you could say, put that in the swear jar. And then if they do say a swear word, you pull out what they could have said instead. You know, these fun games that dad has to do too. But swearing can be quite a release and that’s fine. But knowing when and where to release that is very important and not great for children who don’t have great control over their emotions anyway. And you want them to learn better words. You want them to learn more descriptive words. You want them to learn words that pack more of a punch. So yeah, you have to be patient with some of it. And you want to also use it as a teaching opportunity for the entire family.

Julianna 04:47
Yes. And I agree. I mean, you don’t want your kids swearing at other kids.

Kelley 04:47
No. And then those kids are starting to swear and everything. That’s just not good. All right. Ready for the next one?

Julianna 04:47
Yes, I am.

Kelley 04:47
“Will my child ever talk? My kid is 5, has been in ABA 5 hours a day for the last 2 years and not making any progress in language. I am so frustrated.” So what do you have to say to that parent?

Julianna 05:09
It’s frustrating.

Kelley 05:09
Yeah. And will they ever talk?

Julianna 05:10
I’m going to ask lots of questions.

Kelley 05:18
Yes.

Julianna 05:18
I know that your child is five.

Kelley 05:18
Five whole years old. Right.

Julianna 05:18
I know your child is five. I know you’ve tried ABA. I don’t know what else you’ve tried.

Kelley 05:23
I don’t see speech therapy.

Julianna 05:23
I don’t see speech therapy, which seemed like a no brainer. No offense.

Kelley 05:28
Yeah. 

Julianna

But, yeah, I don’t know what you’ve tried. I don’t know how consistent you’ve been. I don’t know what your child’s disabilities are.

Kelley 05:37
Right.

Julianna 05:38
I don’t know if your child will ever talk. And they may not. 

Kelley

So there’s lots of things that need to happen that you need to do. One is to make peace with, they may not ever talk. But so there were a lot of comments, some of them shades of bad, some of them shades of good. I compiled the ones that I like the best. Make sure that the ABA therapist is incorporating alternative communication strategies for making needs known, probably the most important thing.

Julianna 06:04
Yes. And I think with ABA, most of us learned a little sign language.

Kelley 06:16
Sign language, red cards, good old PECS. They may never talk, but if they have mastered a PECS or some of the great AAC device tools that we never had. You need that as much as you need speech and language. If not, cut back on so much ABA and work with a speech therapist to work on alternative communication and not just words. So I want to say this because I often reference the first speech therapist that we ever went to. And there was a child that used to, they used to have therapy before we did. And one day we came a little early and you could see through a window. She was literally on top of the child. She had him pinned, but the mom was in there with her. So it was something that they had agreed to. And she was just trying to get him to look at her in the eyes. That the whole exercise, the whole speech therapy, was just making him look here. It’s hard for some kids. Well, that’s why she kind of had it pinned down. But she had it done in such a way that it was like a fun play thing. And then they take a break and then the mom would try. And the whole speech therapy class was, look here, look here, look here. And I asked her about it because it seemed so strange to me. And she said, I want him to understand the information’s here. That he can get a laugh. We’re trying to get him to want to see our face so he can connect with our face and not just connect with the toys or with running around the room. We want him here. And I didn’t really quite understand it at the time. And then about a year later, I saw the child again, and he was sitting up at the table and they were doing a tabletop game together. And I didn’t even recognize them, but I recognized the mom. And I went, oh, my God. And she said, can you believe it? And I said, I know I can. And she said, he may never be verbal, but we’re thrilled. And I never forgot her because he was understanding the connection. And you know, why kids don’t talk is a very complicated thing that nobody really knows. But you can still get that interaction, that relationship, that look here for mom for help, look here for mom for guidance. And I mean, it made an enormous difference in that child’s life. So that’s huge. Don’t focus on the words. Focus on the connection, the communication, and what you can do together so that the child knows to turn to you. 

Julianna

And this goes without saying, but I’m going to say it anyway. If you are going to social media and asking these questions, don’t ask a question like, why won’t my kid talk?

Kelley 09:33
Just to make yourself feel better you want to hear the magic bullet. 

Julianna

I don’t know if there were any negative comments. I don’t think people are going to troll this mom. You obviously want the response, yes, of course they’re going to talk and just hang in there and do these things. But that’s also not reality.

Kelley 09:55
Yeah. I hope that this parent took the advice that was hanging there. You haven’t been doing this long enough. Five years old is not long enough. Make sure that you are asking questions about alternative communications. There’s a tremendous amount of education a parent needs to do. 

Julianna 10:18
I guess my point is you’re asking the wrong question to the wrong crowd.

Kelley 10:19
Yes. All right, all right. “Glass child syndrome. Is it a real thing? Someone in my family claims that being too accommodating of my PDA child will worsen the glass child syndrome in my other children. Makes me feel so guilty, and I do not know what to do.” So is glass child syndrome—

Julianna 10:44
Okay, go to our episode about siblings. And from our siblings, we learned—

Kelley 10:44
Absolutely.

Julianna 10:55
Yes, glass child syndrome is real. I don’t know if you had more information about this particular family. How old are the kids?

Kelley 10:56
She didn’t say. The whole PDA style of parenting does not have great answers for siblings other than keep them separated and try to carve out time for the sibling. 

Julianna

But I ask because I think it’s interesting that she sounds like she’s probably in the thick of it and she’s already aware of glass child syndrome. So if you’re aware of even this idea that your sibling could feel invisible, which is glass child syndrome, pay attention to that. Why wouldn’t you?

Kelley 11:52
Well, I agree, but, real or not, whatever you want to call it, we didn’t have the terminology glass child syndrome—

Julianna 11:52
No, but we knew that our kid might feel ignored. Or that we were focusing a lot of our attention on our kid who needed a lot of attention, and that that might have effects. And we certainly liked to keep it separated.

Kelley 12:05
You know, we talk a lot about this in the sibling episode. You do the best you can and you know that you’re separating them for their own safety and all these other things, but you know that the consequence is they are going to feel removed from the situation. And again, it’s not the right question to be asking.

Julianna 12:27
Yeah, do I really have to pay attention to my other kid? That’s the question you’re asking is, do I need to focus my attention on the sibling? Am I messing that kid up by doing this?

Kelley 12:46
Go to our paper that the siblings of our neurodivergent children helped us write. They do a wonderful job of outlining how they got through those feelings and things that helped and things that didn’t help. So it is a real thing. Parents need to take it seriously. It is not a good thing to not carve out time for the siblings and to not make sure that you are addressing their mental health.

Julianna 13:12
Yes. And get them therapy when they’re ready for it. Because let’s be honest, they’re going to need some therapy.

Kelley 13:23
Yeah.

Julianna 13:24
That was our takeaway from that episode. That is what our siblings told us. When they are ready, they will need therapy.

Kelley 13:34
Yes. “My five year old child has meltdowns that are physical, but only with me. We have been doing ABA play therapy and he has an IEP through the school district. I am a single parent with full custody, but have a partner who is not the parent. And my child’s behavior is leading to conflict on how to best parent these behaviors. Need advice. Nothing is working. And we have been trying for three years.”

Julianna 14:00
Okay. 

Kelley

Okay. So my first thing is three years isn’t long enough.

Julianna 14:00
Violent behavior and it’s only directed toward her.

Kelley 14:10
So there was a time when you and I would have been like, well, he’s only doing it to me, thank God. 

Julianna 14:15
He went to school and he had a good day at school. I’ll take it. I’ll take it. I’ll do whatever I can to help him feel comfortable.

Kelley 14:20
I just want to point out a couple things that this child is dealing with: a father figure or mother figure, whatever. We don’t know the gender. But somebody that is not their parent. So that might be some of the conflict. There might be some sort of residential, I don’t know, irritation.

Julianna 14:46
So many questions.

Kelley 14:46
So many questions. Where is the behavior coming from?

Julianna 14:46
So again, you’ve got to find out what is triggering the behavior.

Kelley 14:56
What is the antecedent? So if your ABA therapist is not helping you figure out an antecedent behavior, this should be a program. This is one of the reasons why ABA should be in the home. The ABA therapist should be helping you with that. Are they witnessing any of that so that they can help you determine that antecedent? Physical behavior often stems from the inability to communicate effectively another way. So find out what they want to communicate. It could be a sensory issue, it could be a regulation issue, it could be anxiety, it could be all kinds of things.

Julianna 15:44
Yes, but you don’t want physical aggression to continue. I’ve been in that space and I remember as my child was getting bigger and I was starting to get concerned about, oh, what’s going to happen when he outweighs me or I am not strong enough anymore to restrain him and do those things. These are real things and you need help with them. So if it’s been three years, I do think it’s time you need to get professional help.

Kelley 15:55
Well, they have ABA. So what is it? Put it back on the ABA. Put it back on the ABA therapist. Say this bumps up to the top of the list. So you need immediate strategies. So things to do in the immediate tantrum, things that are the aggression.

Julianna 16:08
If you need to learn self restraint, you need to learn self restraint. Things that are long term, figuring out antecedents, ways to avoid triggers and then better communication skills for long, long term. Perhaps some medication.

Kelley 16:24
Perhaps a little bit of medication. I wanted to say that the point about the conflict between the partner and getting physical because you’re bigger than the five year old so that they stop because they’re scared of you is never the answer.

Julianna 16:34
That does not build good communication. 

Kelley

And if you are with someone, even if they are the biological parent and they think that you should be spanking and you should spank, absolutely not. And Iwould  use the ABA therapist to help that person understand why that’s not a great idea. It’s just a band aid on a bullet hole.

Julianna 16:52
And worse than just a band aid, it is probably going to escalate the situation.

Kelley 17:00
And you’re teaching your kid how to hit, right? So you don’t ever want to do that. You want to teach the kid to use their words, to de-escalate, to self regulate. It’s a long and painful process, but it will fruit. And hitting will give you immediate fruit and then you’ll find them hitting people later. Now, balancing compliance. “Is compliance bad? My wife insists that we should not make our teen shower if he does not want to because it is his body, his choice, and we should not make him do something that he may have a perfectly valid reason for not wanting to do. I say he stinks and I cannot handle being around it.”

Julianna 18:07
Okay, I think we’re abusing the “my body, my choice” expression. I think this is not what this is referring to.

Kelley 18:15
What do you mean? I just used it for my—

Julianna 18:15
I know, again, I think we’re now diluting it. So if you stink, you stink.

Kelley 18:21
You stink. Right? Yes, you are making a choice, but you share space with other people. Well, I think it’s interesting, this whole idea about how we’re raising them to be compliant and they might have a very valid reason for not wanting to shower.

Julianna 18:37
Do you know that they have a valid reason?

Kelley 18:37
If you believe they have a valid reason for not wanting to shower, then that’s where the conversation starts. If they generally don’t like water hitting on them or then a bath.

Julianna 18:50
Right. Get some wipes out. I don’t know. There are ways to get clean.

Kelley 18:50
No, because it’s your body, your choice and because compliance with things that are arbitrary to you doesn’t it’s not going to serve you. There is a very valid reason why you should be hygienic. And I encourage parents to constantly be weighing the pros and cons. What is the harm in letting him be. 

Julianna

And it’s just very short sighted.

Kelley 19:18
It is.

Julianna 19:18
I would argue that hygiene, personal hygiene, is not arbitrary.

Kelley 19:18
No.

Julianna 19:18
That you are going to hopefully live a long full life among other people. And if we all were just arbitrary about our hygiene, that would become unpleasant.

Kelley 19:36
Yeah. I think as a family you need to decide what the absolute musts are. And shared spaces are a must. Taking care of yourself, self care. And that includes being clean. There are real consequences to not brushing your teeth and washing your body. There are real physical consequences. There are real consequences. So that’s why it’s non-negotiable. Putting the work into helping the child understand why that matters. 

Julianna

You can bring it to their level and just say you like playing with so and so, but they’re not going to like playing with you because you stink.

Kelley 20:08
And you can’t smell yourself, but it smells like this. To demonstrate something that’s unpleasant to them. All of those things are getting to the why of water, wash, shower. And if it is the method of delivery of the cleanliness, help them work on alternatives. That is valid. If showering is a sensory thing, and a lot of people in the comments had to say that there’s situations of abuse, that abuse happens in bathrooms, and that this is very valid, particularly for a nonverbal person to be apprehensive about being naked. If you feel this is a problem, I mean, that’s very specific. 

Julianna

That’s very different. That’s not arbitrary.

Kelley 20:51
Making an arbitrary rule that we all need to shower every day. And that’s not even sensory. That is a trauma, and that needs to be addressed. Even if that is the reason why you don’t like to shower, not showering is furthering the trauma. It is not helping you heal from the trauma. I don’t like those comments where it’s like, okay, now you’re making this another thing.

Julianna 21:11
Yeah, totally. Of course, I’m not for abuse and trauma by suggesting that your kids should shower.

Kelley 21:18
Right? 

Julianna 21:18
No, I’m not doing that. But I think that this is a little outsized reaction to a compliance question.

Kelley 21:33
Right. Okay. TW, you know that I’m going to love the posts that have a trigger warning, because some of the groups require you to put a TW so that people that might be triggered by what you’re saying can scroll past it.

Julianna 21:51
They need a warning sign.

Kelley 21:51
Okay. You ready for the warning? “TW: trying ABA. Don’t hate me.” I knew you were going to have that reaction. ABA, it’s triggering. That requires a trigger warning. It’s bad, right?

Julianna 22:18
If that’s triggering and you are parenting a child with autism. Wow. Okay. That aside, I’m ready. I’m warned.

Kelley 22:27
Yeah. “We have tried everything else, but we need more tools for our home, specifically sibling violence, sleep, and toileting. So far, the therapist has been very helpful.”

Julianna 22:39
So they’re already doing it.

Kelley 22:39
Okay. “And doing some awesome things. And I helped the BCBA write the goals. What else should I be doing? I do not want to traumatize my child with ABA.”

Julianna 22:48
Okay, wait, but you’ve got sibling violence. That’s not more triggering, apparently?

Kelley 23:03
So the ABA is the issue. Okay, so the moderator commented and then turned off comments. And I’m pointing this out to you because it goes with our continued theme that these people don’t know you. These people are strangers, you are in a silo. The answer is ABA wrong. So don’t go here expecting vindication.

Julianna 23:20
And I would argue if you’ve been using ABA and you want to talk about ABA and you’re going to a group that you know is going to be triggered by ABA, what answer do you think you’re going to get?

Kelley 23:35
So this is the answer that the moderator gives before shutting down the comments. Because I have found in these PDA groups that a lot of people will say, we do it and it’s fine. We’re getting a good response. And oh, that is not acceptable. That is not acceptable. “ABA is counter indicated for PDA. It is not considered best practice. We don’t advocate for ABA here. So it’s impossible for us to help you maximize your chances of ABA helping your PDA kid. It can’t. By design. Behaviorism is inherently problematic. We allow posts like this for the sake of education. So I’m including a wealth of resources for you. And then I’m closing the comments so we don’t have to heavily moderate the post.” Yeah, so they don’t have to moderate people saying, it’s fine.

Julianna 24:18
Yeah, we like it. Keep, keep, keep trying or, you know.

Kelley 24:25
Just kick people out of the group like they used to do with me. Unless you

Julianna 

How are you in this group?

Kelley 24:26
Oh, I keep, I keep myself silent in this sucker because I know better because I’ve been kicked out of so many.

Julianna 24:40
It’s definitely not your first rodeo.

Kelley 24:40
No. “Unless you’ve worked with PDA affirming OTs and therapists, which BCBAs are not. They are not PDA affirming. Then there’s so much more you can lean into from the perspective of relational neuroscience and PDA. Best practice compliance training via ABA is simply not the answer.” Cue to my last question about compliance. “The wrong therapy is worse than none, even when you have sibling violence. Please feel free to submit another post sharing what difficulties you’re experiencing, and those of us here with more experience may be able to offer you guidance.” What do you think of that?

Julianna 25:14
That’s it. And nobody shared any guidance.

Kelley 25:17
Well, they weren’t allowed to. She turned the comments off. You are supposed to share in a new post. Which she didn’t, or I don’t think she did. Maybe I didn’t see it, whatever. But the point of me sharing this is this is not a place for discussion. This is not a place to share ideas. This is not a place to say ABA is what I have access to. How do I maximize its potential? How do I write programs? This place is ABA bad. So don’t go there. And you don’t owe those people anything. You are not joining a group. You are not joining a social movement. You are raising a child. And save your money. Because when you get further into the PDA resources, they’re all a version of antecedent behavior consequences. All of them are. It’s kick the can down the road until you actually can’t anymore. And then you’re going to have to put up with a little meltdown and walk back a little.

Julianna 26:12
What about sibling violence? 

Kelley 26:33
Keep them separated is the main advice they give. But the problem parents run into is they keep them separated. They keep them separated. The child that is struggling with PDA-like behaviors and doesn’t acclimate to a new routine. They acclimate to the routine of them dominating your time, them being on their screen, them not wanting to leave the house. And pretty soon you have less and less time for your siblings. So you kicked a can down the road. And then you’re like, I have to do something with my other child. I can’t. This child’s going to have to stay at home. But then the child won’t without you. So it becomes this whole thing.

Julianna 26:46
There are many sad parts of this, but one of the sad parts is the original poster. She is in some crisis here.

Kelley 27:02
Yeah. 

Julianna 27:02
And looking for some help.

Kelley 27:11
And obviously she identifies her child as having PDA. She wouldn’t be in this group. And that really puts her in a spot because she believes that this criteria fits her child. 

Julianna

But she’s really not being given any resources.

Kelley 27:12
No, there was a big list of resources. And they’re all these parenting coaches who aren’t licensed or who are licensed but don’t accept insurance. So you have to pay out of pocket for them. And it’s just a cottage industry. And the most important thing is when you get to the bottom of what they’re doing, it’s basically a version of ABA. It is a new vernacular for tried and true technique. And stripping away more demands, figuring out what’s going on, all of that is a version of ABA.

Julianna 28:02
Right, antecedent. Antecedent is the principal of ABA.

Kelley 28:02
So they sell that. So they’re trying to steal what works and call it something else. And that’s fine if it works for your family, that’s fine if you can unschool. That’s fine if you only have one child or if you have two children that work well in that model. But if it’s not working for you, it’s okay to bail on it. And you will also find that in many of these groups, there are many parents that are doing just that, but they don’t say it because they’re not allowed to, because they’ll either get kicked out or the comment will get shut down. But rest assured that there are parents of PDA-ers doing plenty of ABA.

Julianna 28:35
Interesting.

Kelley 28:36
Yeah, thanks for tuning in. Let us know what you think. Where can they find us, Julianna?

Julianna 28:54
They can find us on TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, our website, refrigeratormoms.com, and you can listen to us anywhere you get your podcasts. And go to the YouTube channel if you want to see what we look like and what Kelley’s notes look like.

Julianna 29:01
All right, thanks for listening. Bye. 

Kelley

Bye. 

Julianna 29:01
Thank you for listening to this episode of Refrigerator Moms. Don’t forget to subscribe so you never miss an episode. You can also find episode notes, resources, and any refrigerator paper connected to today’s discussion on our website at refrigeratormoms.com, where you can sign up for our newsletter. We’d love to hear your questions and future episode ideas. Reach out to us on social media or through our website.

The information shared in this podcast is meant for informational and educational purposes only. It shouldn’t be taken as medical, psychological, therapeutic, legal, or professional advice. If you have questions about a diagnosis, treatment, intervention, or any medical or developmental concerns, please consult a qualified healthcare or service provider. Don’t rely on this podcast in place of professional guidance, and don’t delay getting help because of something you heard here. The views and experiences we talk about are our own and those of our guests.

They’re not meant to serve as personalized recommendations for any individual or family. Listening to this podcast does not create any kind of professional relationship between you and the hosts or guests. Any choices you make based on the information here are completely your own, and we are not responsible for any outcomes that result from them. If this episode includes a refrigerator paper, you can find all sources and citations along with additional notes on our website at refrigeratormoms.com.

This transcript has been edited for clarity and readability.  

Share the Post: